TakeOnIt
Compare opinions of world leading experts and influencers.
  HIV    Sex    Health    Topic Index  Add Expert Opinion    Edit Question    Edit Implications    History   

Is circumcision worthwhile?

Male circumcision is an ancient ritualistic removal of foreskin from the penis that remains prevalent to this day in countries such as the US. While it seems that it has negligible health impacts in the majority of cases, the procedure is not without medical advantages and disadvantages. On the whole, is it worthwhile?

Related Questions


Experts and Influencers

Suggest Expert Quote (click to expand, no login required)
Agree
Disagree
Experts In Health


Dimitri Christakis    Pediatrics Professor
Disagree
We're talking about trade-offs for very rare risks and very rare benefits. Now, I can tell parents that one in 500 circumcised children may suffer a complication, and one in 100 children may derive a benefit. But people will weigh that differently. However, the vast majority of children will gain no medical benefit nor suffer any complication as a result of circumcision.
11 Jan 2000    Source


Experts In Economics


The Economist    Politics and Business Magazine
Disagree
Circumcision and other forms of male-genital mutilation are commonplace in many societies around the world. The origin of these practices, however, puzzles anthropologists and evolutionary biologists. They wonder what benefit they could bring, especially given the obvious risks of infection and reduced fertility.
19 Jul 2008    Source



Comments

Add Your TakeOnIt (click to expand, no login required)
0 Points      Malcolm G      01 Feb 2009      Stance on Question: Mostly Disagree
Medically, unless there are complications, I think it is unnesessary.


0 Points      Benja      19 Oct 2008      Editorial Comment
Perhaps the question should be reworded in terms of medical benefits.


0 Points      Lulu      06 Sep 2008      Editorial Comment
when i read Christakis' quote "However, the vast majority of children will gain no medical benefit nor suffer any complication as a result of circumcision." i thought it was a "neutral" comment, rather than disagree....??