TakeOnIt
Compare opinions of world leading experts and influencers.

Is intelligent extraterrestrial life common in our galaxy?

Currently, Earth is the only planet in the universe known to have life. The ongoing SETI program monitors electromagnetic radiation from outer space in the hope of detecting an intelligent signal.

Implications to Other Questions


Experts and Influencers

Suggest Expert Quote (click to expand, no login required)
Agree
Experts In Astronomy


Carl Sagan    Astronomy Professor, Writer, Emmy Award Winner
Mostly Agree
Some scientists working on the question of extraterrestrial intelligence, myself among them, have attempted to estimate the number of advanced technical civilizations in the Milky Way galaxy - that is, societies capable of radio astronomy. Such estimates are little better than guesses [but] when we do the arithmetic, the number that my colleagues and I come up with is around a million technical civilizations in our Galaxy alone.
01 Jan 1978    Source


Frank Drake    Former Astronomy Professor
Mostly Agree
...I tried to estimate the number of planets in our galaxy with intelligent, technological civilizations. The result has come to be called the Drake equation. But I've recently realized that [we] underestimated the number of possible life-sustaining planets because we thought they had to be confined to a particular orbit: within the continuously habitable zone... We used to think N was about 10,000. Now I think it could be a great deal larger.
01 Dec 2004    Source


Disagree
Experts In Science


Robin Hanson    Economics Professor
Mostly Disagree
No alien civilizations have substantially colonized our solar system or systems nearby. Thus among the billion trillion stars in our past universe, none has reached the level of technology and growth that we may soon reach. This one data point implies that a Great Filter stands between ordinary dead matter and advanced exploding lasting life. And the big question is: How far along this filter are we?
15 Sep 1998    Source


Peter Ward    Biology and Earth Sciences Professor
Mostly Disagree
In my view, life in the form of microbes or their equivalents is very common in the universe, perhaps more common than even Drake and Sagan envisioned. However, complex life -- animals and higher plants -- is likely to be far more rare than commonly assumed. Life on Earth evolved from single celled organisms to multi-cellular creatures with tissues and organs, climaxing in animals and higher plants.
15 Jul 2002    Source


Experts In Physics


Max Tegmark    Professor of Physics
Disagree
...if advanced civilizations have evolved in many of [the countless other solar systems, many of which are billions of years older than ours] then some have a vast head start on us — so where are they? I don't buy the explanation that they're all choosing to keep a low profile: natural selection operates on all scales, and as soon as one life form adopts expansionism (sending off rogue self-replicating interstellar nanoprobes, say), others can't afford to ignore it.
01 Jan 2007    Source



Comments

Add Your TakeOnIt (click to expand, no login required)
0 Points      Clive      28 Jul 2009      Stance on Question: Neutral
I would image it's hard to know for sure if there's extra terrestrial life out there. I am curious about the possibilities of bacterial life on Mars or Europa, or maybe other planet/moons in our solar system. And I think it is within our technological abilities to know for sure.


0 Points      jeetender      18 Jan 2010      Stance on Question: Agree
I donot no much of theories but I agrre that there is life elsewhere also.
read some where that "Great Einstien stated that he is knowing and trying to undrestand only a litle part of the nature". may be I shall be giving exact statement later



0 Points      Malcolm G      01 Feb 2009      Stance on Question: Agree
It stands to reason that with 100's of billions of solar systems just in the Milky Way alone that there would be other advanced societies out there.