TakeOnIt
Compare opinions of world leading experts and influencers.

Does smoking cause cancer?

The belief that smoking causes cancer is supported through both epidemiological studies and research into the underlying mechanisms by which smoking damages the body. Skeptics suggest that the epidemiological studies are biased, and that the underlying mechanisms are not yet properly understood.

Related Questions


Experts and Influencers

Suggest Expert Quote (click to expand, no login required)
Agree
Experts In Health


Stephen Hecht    Professor of Medicine
Agree
Collectively, the evidence favoring the sequence of steps [that result in smoking causing cancer] is extremely strong, although there are important aspects of each step that require further study. These include carcinogen metabolism and DNA binding in human lung, the effects of cigarette smoke on DNA repair and adduct persistence, the relationship between specific carcinogens and mutations in critical genes, and the sequence of gene changes leading to lung cancer.
21 Jul 1999    Source


US Department of Health & Human Services    (HHS) Government Department
Agree
...the health effects of smoking provides a startling picture of the damage to health caused by tobacco use. Smoking injures almost all bodily organs, and tragically this injury often leads to incurable disease and death. The comprehensive review process that is the foundation of this series of reports has found new causal associations of smoking with disease, reemphasizing the need for continued monitoring of scientific evidence on the health effects of smoking.
01 Jan 2004    Source


Disagree
Experts In Science


Peter Finch    Statistics Professor
Disagree
First, studies which in any other area of science would be rejected as second-rate and inferior but which support antismoking are accepted as first-rate. Second, studies which are conducted according to orthodox and rigorous design but which do not support the idea that smoking is harmful are not merely ignored but suppressed. Third, authorities who are duty-bound to represent the truth have failed to do so and have presented not just untruths but the reverse of the truth.
31 Jul 2006    Source


Neutral
Experts In Science


Robin Hanson    Economics Professor
Neutral
So we don’t have clear evidence that smoking kills; it could be that most or all of the death-smoking correlations are due to selection effects, and not smoking causing death. ... Apparently we need bigger trials if we are going to see clearly if smoking kills. Alas the era of the large risk trial seems to be over, at least for now; it seems it will be a long time before we really know.
14 Dec 2009    Source


Ambiguous or Flip-Flop
Experts In Business


Philip Morris    Tobacco Company
Agree
[There is] overwhelming medical and scientific consensus that cigarette smoking causes [diseases including lung cancer, emphysema and heart disease.]
13 Oct 1999    Source


Philip Morris    Tobacco Company
Disagree
The tobacco industry itself is more interested than anyone else in finding out and making public the true facts about tobacco and health. Research in recent years has produced findings that weaken rather than support the claim that smoking is a major contributor to lung cancer.
06 Jul 1961    Source



Comments

Add Your TakeOnIt (click to expand, no login required)
0 Points      stopsmokinghabits      18 Mar 2010      Stance on Question: Agree
Smoking refers to the inhalation and exhalation of ejected gases from burning tobacco in cigars,
cigarettes and pipes. Historically, smoking as a practice, was followed by natives of the
Western Hemisphere, in religious rituals and for medicinal purposes. It has a history
starting from the late 1500s.


THE SHOCKING INGREDIENTS:

Ammonia: Household cleaner.
Arsenic: Used in rat poisons.
Benzene: Used in making dyes, synthetic rubber.
Butane: Gas; used in lighter fluid.
Carbon monoxide: Poisonous gas.
Cadmium: Used in batteries.
Cyanide: Lethal poison.
DDT: A banned insecticide.
Ethyl Furoate: Causes liver damage in animals.
Lead: Poisonous in high doses.
Formaldehyde: Used to preserve dead specimens.
Methoprene: Insecticide.
Maltitol: Sweetener for diabetics.
Napthalene: Ingredient in mothballs.
Methyl isocyanate: Its accidental release killed 2000 people in Bhopal, India, in 1984.
Polonium: Cancer-causing radioactive element.


stopsmokinghabits

http://www.stopsmokinghabits.com