TakeOnIt
Compare opinions of world leading experts and influencers.

Economics

Is free trade generally beneficial for a country?
Adam Smith is the founder of the concept of free trade, in his book "The Wealth of Nations" published in 1776. He came up with theoretical arguments showing that governmental barriers to trade such as tariffs and subsidies are ultimately not in the best interests of either side in a trade agreement. Karl Marx, the founder of communism, vigorously disagreed.
Ascendaeus 1 day ago gave their opinion.
Benja 2 days ago added the opinion of:
Milton Friedman
Noam Chomsky

Would the typical entrepreneur be better off as an employee?
The success rates for entrepreneurs are notoriously low. Furthermore, the reasons for their failure often seem quite predictable. This would seem to indicate that the typical entrepreneur, if they rationally assessed their business endeavor, would be better off being an employee.
Benja on 29 Jan 2010 added the opinion of:
Malcolm Gladwell
Donald Trump
Robert Kiyosaki
Scott Shane
Robin Hanson

Are prediction markets the most accurate way to aggregate expert predictions?
Prediction markets allow people to bet money on predictions, with the purpose of providing more accurate predictions for policy and business analysts. Prediction markets are often contrasted with alternative methods used to tap collective intelligence, such as expert committees. Advocates of prediction markets claim that prediction markets are more accurate than their alternatives, but are underutilized due to irrational concerns regarding their accuracy, as well as susceptibility to subversion.
Benja on 27 Jan 2010 added the opinion of:
Justin Wolfers
Paul Hewitt
Science
Matthew Yglesias
Willy Aspinall
Robin Hanson

Tax

Does minimum wage help the poor?
A government can set a minimum wage to legally prevent an employee accepting what is declared to be unfair income from an employer. The strategy is one of many cases of contentious economic regulation, where advocates of free markets may claim its distortionary effects neutralize its supposed benefits.
Benja on 22 Jan 2010 added the opinion of:
Robin Hanson

Does Cap and Trade beat carbon tax for reducing emissions?
The two main competing strategies for lowering carbon emissions are a Cap and Trade system and a carbon tax. A Cap and Trade system works by having a government issue a capped number of carbon credits to companies, where the more polluting companies that exceed their quota must buy carbon credits from the less polluting companies that sell their unused quota. Some of its critics suggest that carbon taxation is simpler and that a Cap and Trade system can be gamed and subverted.
Steve on 20 Dec 2009 added the opinion of:
Robin Hanson
Joseph Stiglitz
Paul Krugman
Al Gore
The Economist
Rex Tillerson
Barack Obama
Joseph Romm
James Hansen

Australia

Is reduced affordability causing a housing bubble in Australia?
House prices as a ratio of household income are at historic highs in Australia. Some people suggest that this is causing a housing bubble, analogous to the United States. Others suggest this ratio is no longer relevant, because other factors have changed.
ABCDiamond on 11 Nov 2009 gave their opinion.

Is there a housing bubble in Australia?
There is intense debate as to whether Australia has a housing bubble. Metrics such as the historically high ratio of house prices to household income, which were indicative of the U.S. housing bubble, suggest a bubble. However, counterclaims suggest that this ratio reflects a permanent shift in the desires of Australian householders, or that a genuine lack of supply is here to stay. In addition, the cause of such a bubble is itself debated.
ABCDiamond on 11 Nov 2009 gave their opinion.

Is capitalism good?
Capitalism is an economic system where wealth is privatized, that is, controlled by individuals. It stands in contrast to socialism, where wealth is controlled by the government. Western economies are said to be capitalist systems, though in reality they are a blend of capitalist and socialist systems, where the left and right wing advocate socialist vs. capitalistic leaning economic policies respectively.
Benja on 10 Mar 2010 added the opinion of:
Milton Friedman
Michael Moore

Is development aid to Africa effective?
Development aid is the donation of money, goods, and services to foreign countries for the purpose of long term development. It is distinct from humanitarian aid, which is focused on short term relief during events such as natural disasters. Many opponents of development aid reluctantly believe factors such as corruption render this form of charity ineffective.
Benja on 05 Mar 2010 added the opinion of:
James Shikwati

Could rising health and retirement costs bankrupt the US?
Entitlement programs, which include Social Security, Medicare, and Medicaid, account for nearly 50% of the US federal budget. As the population ages, there is a fear that rising costs will bankrupt the government.
Benja on 20 Dec 2009 added the opinion of:
Robin Hanson

Do economic sanctions work?
Economic sanctions punitively restrict trade with a country as a result of a political disagreement. Critics of the approach suggest that it doesn't achieve the desired effect.
grumpy on 15 Oct 2009 gave their opinion.

Investing

Is efficient market theory the best approximation of the truth for the average investor?
It is notoriously difficult to outperform the market. This concept is best formalized by the Efficient Market Hypothesis which is based on the insight that the price of a stock continually incorporates all the information that rational investors have access to. The theory is used to explain why actively managed funds over the long run typically fail to outperform an index.
Matarael on 09 Jan 2010 gave their opinion.
Ecogeek on 25 Dec 2009 added the opinion of:
Robin Hanson


All Questions on Economics

Is free trade generally beneficial for a country?
Is capitalism good?
Is development aid to Africa effective?
Is peak oil imminent?
Is substantially reducing CO2 emissions worthwhile?
Does Cap and Trade beat carbon tax for reducing emissions?
Would the typical entrepreneur be better off as an employee?
Was the US government's $700 billion bailout ultimately good for the taxpayer?
Does government spending help mitigate a recession?
Is efficient market theory the best approximation of the truth for the average investor?
Does economic inequality cause crime?
Will energy scarcity cause a severe world depression?
Are prediction markets the most accurate way to aggregate expert predictions?
Does minimum wage help the poor?
Could rising health and retirement costs bankrupt the US?
Do economic sanctions work?
Can nuclear power be economically competitive with other major energy sources?
Did the Fed bailout Bear Stearns to benefit the taxpayer?
Is there a housing bubble in the United States?
Is reduced affordability causing a housing bubble in Australia?
Do Australia's land and housing regulations choke supply?
Should the US Government bail out car companies?
Will Australia enter a recession before 2010?
Is the US Federal Reserve to blame for the 2008 financial crisis?
Does money make you happy?
Is there a housing bubble in Australia?
Will Australia's Housing Affordability Fund work?
Will there be a global recession before 2010?
Is Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac a huge risk to the economy?
Is the world economy largely decoupled from the United States?
Should financial firms be strictly limited in their ability to leverage capital?
Should the Federal Reserve have bailed out Long Term Capital Management?
Does relative wealth make us happier than absolute wealth?
Will oil prices surge over the next year?
Has socioeconomic mobility taken place in India since 1990?
Are biofuels good?
Do software patents stifle innovation?
Can you put a price on life?