TakeOnIt
Compare opinions of world leading experts and influencers.

Philosophy

God

Is God just?
Both western and eastern religions assert that the world is a just place, whether that is made possible by God, or through the subtle workings of the Law of Karma. In contrast, from an atheists perspective, the universe is at best an amoral place. Bad things happen to good people and vice versa; morality is only enforced, if at all, by humans, not God; morality a muddled mosaic of meaning undermined by mortality.
Benja 23 hours ago added the opinion of:
Richard Dawkins

Must God exist to explain how the universe began?
This philosophical question is a form of the Cosmological Argument or First Cause Argument. The question is whether it makes sense that the universe "came into existence from nothing". Modern physics suggests that the notion of time, and hence cause and effect, break down at the time of the big bang, rendering the intuitive demand for a "first cause" meaningless.
JGWeissman on 08 Mar 2010 gave their opinion.

Must all explanations be compatible with the laws of physics?
The laws of physics are foundational to all of science, describing with mathematics the basic ways in which the physical world behaves. Although physics doesn't provide the simplest explanation for everything - we need fields such as biology to explain emergent phenomena like life - it does require all explanations of the world to be compatible with physics. In contrast, some religious thinkers believe that this compatibility is impossible in explaining humanistic concepts such as free will.
Benja 4 days ago added the opinion of:
Mani Norland
The Catholic Church
and 4 days ago gave their opinion.
and 4 days ago gave their opinion.
Packbat 4 days ago added the opinion of:
Galileo Galilei
and 4 days ago gave their opinion.
JGWeissman on 06 Mar 2010 gave their opinion.

Is capitalism good?
Capitalism is an economic system where wealth is privatized, that is, controlled by individuals. It stands in contrast to socialism, where wealth is controlled by the government. Western economies are said to be capitalist systems, though in reality they are a blend of capitalist and socialist systems, where the left and right wing advocate socialist vs. capitalistic leaning economic policies respectively.
Benja on 10 Mar 2010 added the opinion of:
Milton Friedman
Michael Moore

Liberty

Is censorship acceptable?
Censorship limits the freedom of speech and expression, typically by the government, for purported social good. In its most extreme form, it is illegal for people to question the leaders and ideology of the society they live in.
JGWeissman on 08 Mar 2010 added the opinion of:
Eliezer Yudkowsky
and on 06 Mar 2010 gave their opinion.

Evolution

Is humanity likely doomed to destroy itself?
Modern civilization has only emerged over the last few thousand years. Our successes have been accompanied by risks. Our population growth has also damaged our environment, and our wondrous technology has also created terrible weapons. Cynics suggest that the very engine of our success will likely be humanity's doom.
JGWeissman on 07 Mar 2010 gave their opinion.
Benja on 04 Mar 2010 added the opinion of:
Martin Rees
Nick Bostrom
Robin Hanson

Is truthfulness a characteristic of a politician who is good for the people?
Politicians are notorious for their spin, lies, and hypocrisy, frequently making their profession distasteful to the people they represent. However, while truthfulness is generally regarded as an admirable quality in our friends and family members, is it rational to want this quality in our leaders?
JGWeissman on 07 Mar 2010 gave their opinion.
Lisa on 27 Jan 2010 added the opinion of:
Oprah Winfrey

Is democracy the best form of government?
A democracy is a type of government where political power is shared by allowing each citizen to vote. Proponents have various arguments in support of democracy, perhaps the most common being that is affords its citizens the most freedom. Its critics tend to believe that the average citizen is unqualified to vote.
Benja on 25 Jan 2010 added the opinion of:
Hu Jintao
Adolf Hitler
Osama Bin Laden
George W. Bush
Winston Churchill
Robin Hanson

Is cryonics worthwhile?
Cryonics is the preservation of an animal by cooling with the hope that future medical advances can revive that animal. Modern cryonics make use of cryopreservatives to minimize cellular damage caused by freezing, particularly to the brain. Advocates of the procedure typically believe that so long as the critical structure of the brain is preserved, a person could one day be brought back to life.
JGWeissman on 06 Mar 2010 gave their opinion.
Benja on 08 Feb 2010 added the opinion of:
Alcor Life Extension Foundation
Cryogenic Society of America
Ben Best
Invisible Flan
Eliezer Yudkowsky
Andrew Stark
Bryan Caplan
Benjamin Franklin
Robin Hanson

Artificial Intelligence

Is information-theoretic death the most real interpretation of death?
Information-theoretic death is defined as the moment when the neural structures in your brain are destroyed. At that point, it becomes theoretically impossible to bring a person back to life. Some philosophers and scientists regard this as a more real interpretation of death than legal death.
JGWeissman on 06 Mar 2010 gave their opinion.
Benja on 08 Feb 2010 added the opinion of:
Robert Todd Carroll
Eliezer Yudkowsky
Bryan Caplan
Ralph Merkle

Could a computer ever be conscious?
Consciousness, or our awareness of ourselves and the world around us, is central to our existence. Fascinatingly, it is also notoriously difficult to define. Is it unique to humans or other living creatures, or could robots one day have it to?
JGWeissman on 06 Mar 2010 gave their opinion.
Benja on 25 Feb 2010 added the opinion of:
Jeff Hawkins
Bryan Caplan
John Searle
Packbat on 09 Jan 2010 gave their opinion.
Steve on 20 Dec 2009 added the opinion of:
Robin Hanson

Is the unconscious philosophical zombie possible?
The philosophical zombie is a hypothetical person whose behavior is indistinguishable from an ordinary person, but who lacks conscious experience. The zombie might say "the strawberry is red" but they would not experience the qualia of red, that is, the sensation of red. Some philosophers allege that the theoretical possibility of such a zombie undermines physicalism.
JGWeissman on 06 Mar 2010 gave their opinion.
Benja on 06 Jan 2010 added the opinion of:
John Searle
Susan Blackmore
Todd Moody
Daniel Dennett
David Chalmers
Eliezer Yudkowsky

Should euthanasia be legal?
Euthanasia is the act of mercifully ending someone's life, such as a terminally ill patient. It can be voluntary (where the patient gives consent) or involuntary (where the patient is unable to communicate). It can also be via action (e.g. a drug overdose) or inaction (cutting off life support). Euthanasia also encompasses assisted suicide, where a physician enables the patient to perform the act.
Iconoclast on 27 Nov 2009 gave their opinion.

Futurism

Is living forever or having a greatly extended lifespan desirable?
The average life expectancy in developed countries is at best 80 years. Advances in technology may inhibit or even reverse aging, to open up the possibility of living extraordinarily long times. However, would this actually be a good thing for society, or even for the long-living individual?
Packbat 3 days ago gave their opinion.
JGWeissman on 06 Mar 2010 gave their opinion.
Benja on 08 Feb 2010 added the opinion of:
Bryan Caplan
Eliezer Yudkowsky
Leon Kass
Ben Best
Robert Todd Carroll

Can you put a price on life?
It is frequently claimed that you can't put a price on life. However, this view is somewhat contradicted by our real-world institutions, such as healthcare, insurance, and justice, which often do precisely that. Is putting a price tag on a person justified?
Benja 3 days ago added the opinion of:
Peter Singer
Sarah Palin
Michele Bachmann
Ezekiel Emanuel
Glenn Blomquist
Andrew Von Eschenbach
Doug Casey

Are our enemies innately evil?
It's easy to label our enemies "evil", as if they must know what they're doing is wrong, but decide to do it anyway. However, the alternative view is that our enemies have moral justifications for their actions, and believe in their righteousness just as much as we do.
Benja 5 days ago added the opinion of:
Richard Dawkins
Kevin Rudd
John Judis
Albert Mohler
Hannah Arendt
Hugo Chávez
Friedrich Nietzsche
Osama Bin Laden
George W. Bush
Dale Carnegie
Eliezer Yudkowsky
and 5 days ago gave their opinion.
Joe 5 days ago gave their opinion.

Is free will an illusion?
The belief that we control our decisions is seemingly undermined by the fact that the future is an inevitable consequence of the past. When we put our foot on a car's accelerator, we know that this causes chemical combustion in the car, and that the car has no choice but to go faster. Similarly, the putting of our foot on the accelerator was also caused by chemical combustion - one in our own brains. For this reason, many philosophers and scientists regard free will as illusionary.
JGWeissman on 08 Mar 2010 added the opinion of:
Eliezer Yudkowsky
and on 06 Mar 2010 gave their opinion.

Is the world explainable without God?
Many religious thinkers do not find a purely scientific account of the universe plausible. Areas where the scientific explanation is questioned include the universe's origin, life on earth, human consciousness, and human morality.
JGWeissman on 08 Mar 2010 gave their opinion.

Is there life after death?
One of the major clashes between the scientific world view and religious world views, is that science does not support a belief in life after death. Christianity and Islam regard life as preparation for judgement at death, which will determine one's fate in the afterlife. Judaism regards death as not the end, but is much less focused on the afterlife than life itself. Buddhism and Hinduism believe in continual rebirth until enlightenment is attained.
JGWeissman on 06 Mar 2010 gave their opinion.
Steve on 01 Dec 2009 added the opinion of:
Albert Einstein
Praveen on 13 Nov 2009 gave their opinion.

Do we have an immaterial soul?
The belief in an immaterial soul requires that central aspects of a person, such as consciousness, memories, and personality, are not contingent upon our physical bodies. The concept was first formalized in western philosophy by Rene Descartes in the 17th century, who proposed that our soul interacts with our body via the pineal gland in the brain. That theory has since been rejected by mainstream science.
JGWeissman on 06 Mar 2010 gave their opinion.

Is revenge OK?
Revenge is similar to justice, except that the intent is personal rather than impartial, and is often in excess of fair retaliation.
Benja on 20 Dec 2009 added the opinion of:
Old Testament
Bryan Caplan

Is suicide morally acceptable?
While the underlying reasons for suicide are complex and a matter of ongoing research, its defenders generally regard it as a means to escape suffering or to spare other people of suffering. The morality of the act has been studied by both philosophers and religious scholars.
Iconoclast on 27 Nov 2009 added the opinion of:
Immanuel Kant
Steve on 27 Nov 2009 added the opinion of:
Johann Hari
G. K. Chesterton
David Foster Wallace
milkfloatgunner on 26 Nov 2009 gave their opinion.
mkearns on 18 Nov 2009 gave their opinion.

Is truth relative?
Is it meaningful to talk of "my truth" and "your truth" where both of us "right"? Critics of relativism say that such talk dilutes the very essence of truth.
JGWeissman on 06 Mar 2010 gave their opinion.
Packbat on 05 Mar 2010 gave their opinion.
Benja on 05 Mar 2010 added the opinion of:
Eliezer Yudkowsky
Isaac Asimov

Is it ethical to eat meat?
Vegetarians choose not to eat meat due for a variety of reasons such as the poor treatment of animals, the belief that killing animals is wrong if avoidable, and the negative environmental impact of animal farming. Meat-eaters see an animal's life with much lower value than a human life, and sometimes use naturalistic arguments to justify meat-eating, pointing out that humans are one of many animals that have evolved to eat meat.
Benja on 16 Dec 2009 added the opinion of:
Robin Hanson

Is "good" art purely subjective?
Art is a form of expression that is purely creative with the purpose of stimulating our imagination rather than being obviously useful to us. Art is often used synonymously with visual art, but the term also applies more generally to other mediums, such as music, literature, and dance. Anyone who is passionate about art feels that there is good art and bad art, but is that feeling objectively justifiable in any way?
gcha on 01 Dec 2009 added the opinion of:
Immanuel Kant

Is homosexuality natural?
Opponents of gay rights assert that homosexuality is a recent sickness of society that has temporarily upset our natural heterosexual state of being. Gay advocates retort that this claim is demonstratively false, since homosexuality occurs frequently in many species. Furthermore, they point out that the question is irrelevant due to the "Appeal to Nature" fallacy, which lures people into concluding that if something is unnatural or outside of the norm then it isn't good.
milkfloatgunner on 26 Nov 2009 gave their opinion.


All Questions on Philosophy

Is God just?
Can you put a price on life?
Must all explanations be compatible with the laws of physics?
Are our enemies innately evil?
Were the 9/11 hijackers cowardly?
Is capitalism good?
Is "good" art purely subjective?
Is free will an illusion?
Is censorship acceptable?
Is truth relative?
Is it worthwhile to die for your beliefs?
Is the death penalty acceptable?
Is humanity likely doomed to destroy itself?
Should euthanasia be legal?
Is cryonics worthwhile?
Is there life after death?
Do we have an immaterial soul?
Must God exist to explain how the universe began?
Is democracy the best form of government?
Could a computer ever be conscious?
Does God exist?
Is information-theoretic death the most real interpretation of death?
Is abortion morally acceptable?
Is living forever or having a greatly extended lifespan desirable?
Is masturbation morally acceptable?
Are people who reject theories as unscientific closed minded?
Is truthfulness a characteristic of a politician who is good for the people?
Is hope good?
Is it acceptable to target (i.e. kill) civilians in war?
Is revenge OK?
Is the world explainable without God?
Is "good" music purely subjective?
Is suicide morally acceptable?
Is torture ever justified?
Is the unconscious philosophical zombie possible?
Is it ethical to eat meat?
Is homosexuality natural?
Is abortion wrong because it destroys the potential for life?
Is the value of a life proportional to its level of consciousness?
Does life have a meaning?
Is quantum mechanics needed to explain consciousness?
Were the atomic bombs dropped on Japan justified?
Is there a Law of Karma?
Is a "Theory of Everything" that unifies quantum mechanics and general relativity possible?
Is affirmative action fair?
Is animal vivisection ever ethical?