TakeOnIt
Compare opinions of world leading experts and influencers.

Politics

Is free trade generally beneficial for a country?
Adam Smith is the founder of the concept of free trade, in his book "The Wealth of Nations" published in 1776. He came up with theoretical arguments showing that governmental barriers to trade such as tariffs and subsidies are ultimately not in the best interests of either side in a trade agreement. Karl Marx, the founder of communism, vigorously disagreed.
Ascendaeus 1 day ago gave their opinion.
Benja 2 days ago added the opinion of:
Milton Friedman
Noam Chomsky

Is truthfulness a characteristic of a politician who is good for the people?
Politicians are notorious for their spin, lies, and hypocrisy, frequently making their profession distasteful to the people they represent. However, while truthfulness is generally regarded as an admirable quality in our friends and family members, is it rational to want this quality in our leaders?
JGWeissman on 07 Mar 2010 gave their opinion.
Lisa on 27 Jan 2010 added the opinion of:
Oprah Winfrey

Is democracy the best form of government?
A democracy is a type of government where political power is shared by allowing each citizen to vote. Proponents have various arguments in support of democracy, perhaps the most common being that is affords its citizens the most freedom. Its critics tend to believe that the average citizen is unqualified to vote.
Benja on 25 Jan 2010 added the opinion of:
Hu Jintao
Adolf Hitler
Osama Bin Laden
George W. Bush
Winston Churchill
Robin Hanson

Is development aid to Africa effective?
Development aid is the donation of money, goods, and services to foreign countries for the purpose of long term development. It is distinct from humanitarian aid, which is focused on short term relief during events such as natural disasters. Many opponents of development aid reluctantly believe factors such as corruption render this form of charity ineffective.
Benja on 05 Mar 2010 added the opinion of:
James Shikwati

Do economic sanctions work?
Economic sanctions punitively restrict trade with a country as a result of a political disagreement. Critics of the approach suggest that it doesn't achieve the desired effect.
grumpy on 15 Oct 2009 gave their opinion.

Is nuclear energy safe enough to justify its use?
Nuclear energy has safety challenges with respect to avoiding reactor meltdown, transporting and storing nuclear waste, and mitigating terrorist threats.
Steve on 15 Feb 2010 added the opinion of:
Steven Chu
Ralph Nader

Should the world embrace nuclear energy?
The cost-benefit analysis of nuclear power is complex. Its primary benefit compared with fossil fuels is that it is carbon free. Its primary benefit compared with alternative energy is that it has proven to scale effectively, with approximately 15% of the world's electricity coming from nuclear energy today. Its primary drawback is its safety concerns, including reactor safety, waste disposal, and nuclear proliferation.
Steve on 15 Feb 2010 added the opinion of:
Ralph Nader
Bill Gates

Marijuana

Should marijuana be decriminalized?
Decriminalizing marijuana means reducing criminal charges associated with the possession of marijuana, and for smaller offenses, replacing criminal charges with fines. Decriminalization is not equivalent to legalization.
Steve on 25 Jan 2010 added the opinion of:
Ron Paul
Office of National Drug Control Policy
Barney Frank
Drug Policy Alliance

Could rising health and retirement costs bankrupt the US?
Entitlement programs, which include Social Security, Medicare, and Medicaid, account for nearly 50% of the US federal budget. As the population ages, there is a fear that rising costs will bankrupt the government.
Benja on 20 Dec 2009 added the opinion of:
Robin Hanson

Should performance enhancing drugs be legal in sports?
Anti-doping advocates assert that drugs undermine the spirit of sport, which is about pushing natural human limitations and playing within the rules. However, as sport becomes increasingly high-tech, what is 'natural' becomes harder to define. Defenders of doping also dispute the efficacy of drug enforcement, suggesting that anti-doping rules foster the opposite of fair play.
aman punjab on 22 Sep 2009 gave their opinion.

Tax

Is capitalism good?
Capitalism is an economic system where wealth is privatized, that is, controlled by individuals. It stands in contrast to socialism, where wealth is controlled by the government. Western economies are said to be capitalist systems, though in reality they are a blend of capitalist and socialist systems, where the left and right wing advocate socialist vs. capitalistic leaning economic policies respectively.
Benja on 10 Mar 2010 added the opinion of:
Milton Friedman
Michael Moore

Is censorship acceptable?
Censorship limits the freedom of speech and expression, typically by the government, for purported social good. In its most extreme form, it is illegal for people to question the leaders and ideology of the society they live in.
JGWeissman on 08 Mar 2010 added the opinion of:
Eliezer Yudkowsky
and on 06 Mar 2010 gave their opinion.

Should euthanasia be legal?
Euthanasia is the act of mercifully ending someone's life, such as a terminally ill patient. It can be voluntary (where the patient gives consent) or involuntary (where the patient is unable to communicate). It can also be via action (e.g. a drug overdose) or inaction (cutting off life support). Euthanasia also encompasses assisted suicide, where a physician enables the patient to perform the act.
Iconoclast on 27 Nov 2009 gave their opinion.

Liberty

Should flag burning be legal?
Political activists sometimes desecrate their own country's flag as a protest against the government. Some governments have outlawed the act, while other governments consider it a form of freedom of expression for their citizens.
JGWeissman on 06 Mar 2010 gave their opinion.
Benja on 11 Nov 2009 added the opinion of:
Colin Powell
Ann Coulter
Glenn Beck
Orrin Hatch
Barack Obama
American Civil Liberties Union

Should the US close Guantanamo Bay?
The Guantanamo Bay Detention Camp in Cuba is a POW camp run by the United States. Its critics claim it breaks international law, because its prisoners are abused and held indefinitely without fair trial.
garret on 13 Nov 2009 gave their opinion.

Is the IPCC objective?
The IPCC (Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change) is a scientific body formed by the United Nations in 1988 to summarize research on climate change for the purpose of informing policy makers. Those who are skeptical of anthropogenic global warming have questioned the objectivity of the organization.
Steve on 25 Feb 2010 added the opinion of:
Roy Spencer
Sarah Palin
RealClimate
The Economist
maverick on 11 Dec 2009 added the opinion of:
Roger Pielke

Can the military presence in Afghanistan help create democracy?
A month after the September 11th attacks, the U.S. in conjunction with the U.K. invaded Afghanistan, toppling the Taliban regime that was sympathetic to Al-Qaeda. Kabul, the country's capital, has for decades at best provided only a weak form of central government, and the country quickly descended into anarchy. This prompted the U.N. to create the International Security Assistance Force to help establish peace and security in the region, but to date they have had very limited success.
Benja on 28 Jan 2010 added the opinion of:
Hamid Karzai

Is not bothering to vote acceptable?
Advocates of voting proclaim that voting is the duty of a democratic citizen. Critics say that your vote will almost certainly be inconsequential, since elections are seldom won by a single vote. Furthermore, the critics claim that in the case the parties don't offer significant differences, that the impact of that single vote is reduced.
Benja on 27 Jan 2010 added the opinion of:
Robin Hanson

Is the case for anthropogenic global warming politically biased in its favor?
Anthropogenic Global Warming has become a huge multinational concern, with many people's career and credibility dependent on its truth. As such, some skeptics claim that scientists now fear that challenging the new orthodoxy can result in a lack of funding. Believers have pointed the finger to the fossil fuel industry for spreading misinformation about the facts, and criticized politicians uneasy dealing with the economic impacts of climate change for stonewalling.
Benja on 15 Dec 2009 added the opinion of:
Megan McArdle
Richard Black


All Questions on Politics

Is free trade generally beneficial for a country?
Is capitalism good?
Is abstinence-only sex education effective?
Is censorship acceptable?
Is development aid to Africa effective?
Should religious institutions be separated from government?
Is nuclear energy safe enough to justify its use?
Is the case for anthropogenic global warming politically biased in its favor?
Is it legitimate for the US to label their enemies "terrorists"?
Should robots always be used instead of humans for space exploration?
Should heads of state shun meeting the Dalai Lama to appease China?
Should gay and straight couples have the same legal benefits?
Should euthanasia be legal?
Was Iran's 2009 election rigged?
Does Iran intend to create nuclear weapons?
Is Yucca mountain the best place to store nuclear waste?
Can the military presence in Afghanistan help create democracy?
Is the IPCC objective?
Should the US close Guantanamo Bay?
Was George Bush a good president?
Is substantially reducing CO2 emissions worthwhile?
Can the US military presence in Iraq help create democracy?
Does homosexuality threaten the stability of society?
Is democracy the best form of government?
Must we know the cause of climate change before we try to affect it?
Is the war on drugs good policy?
Should the United States invade Iraq?
Should prostitution be legal?
Is Barack Obama a Muslim?
Can you be patriotic without always having loved your country?
Is not bothering to vote acceptable?
Was the US government's $700 billion bailout ultimately good for the taxpayer?
Does government spending help mitigate a recession?
Did the Taliban ban drug cultivation because it was "un-Islamic"?
Should oil be drilled in Alaska's Arctic National Wildlife Refuge?
Is truthfulness a characteristic of a politician who is good for the people?
Should the world embrace nuclear energy?
Is God on our side in war?
Should the federal government ban gay marriage?
Should homosexual couples be able to adopt kids?
Should flag burning be legal?
Should abortion be legal?
Are politicians' children "off-limits" to media scrutiny?
Does economic inequality cause crime?
Are gun control laws a serious breach of civil liberties?
Is torture ever justified?
Should the US fence its border with Mexico?
Should marijuana be decriminalized?
Can terrorism be dealt with without violence?
Could rising health and retirement costs bankrupt the US?
Do economic sanctions work?
Should the Kyoto protocol be adopted?
Are humans responsible for ozone depletion?
Did the Fed bailout Bear Stearns to benefit the taxpayer?
Is the health risk of a psychoactive drug a legitimate reason to make it illegal?
Should the US Government bail out car companies?
Were the atomic bombs dropped on Japan justified?
Has the US military ever considered terrorizing its own citizens?
Are Iraqis better off since Saddam's regime was toppled?
Should research on stem cells from human embryos be banned?
Are Americans on average stupider than non-Americans?
Was Israel primarily responsible for creating the Palestinian refugee problem?
Should Israel exist as a separate state from Palestine?
Is the US Federal Reserve to blame for the 2008 financial crisis?
Is affirmative action fair?
Is Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac a huge risk to the economy?
Should financial firms be strictly limited in their ability to leverage capital?
Should Australia apologize to the Australian Aborigines for the stolen generations?
Should the Federal Reserve have bailed out Long Term Capital Management?
Is nuclear energy safe enough w/ respect to waste management?
Is nuclear energy safe enough w/ respect to terrorist threats?
Will Barack Obama pick Hillary Clinton for VP, 2008?
Should Iraq be split into three largely autonomous regions?
Is Barack Obama more likely to be assassinated than other US presidents?
Is democracy inevitable?
Should performance enhancing drugs be legal in sports?
Is Russia's invasion of Georgia justified?
Will Barack Obama become president?
Does a presidential candidate's funding significantly affect the chance of victory?
Should the United States have Universal health care?
Should the US privatize Social Security?
Will oil prices surge over the next year?
Will Barack Obama win the Democratic nomination?
Is there political pressure preventing appropriate action to counter climate change?